Essay on "Nations and Nationalism Exist: Comparison"
Essay 4 pages (1187 words) Sources: 5
[EXCERPT] . . . .
This is true most clearly in nations located in the Middle East. Language is held in the work of Laitin and Geertz to be of primary importance in the determination of a nation however, the national language is reported in the work of Hobsbawn to be a "pragmatic matter and still less a dispassionate one, as is show by the reluctance to recognize them as constructs, by historicizing, and inventing traditions for them." (1990) It is noted however, that language for some is viewed as the nation's soul and in some cases is a prerequisite for nationality.Geertz writes that in new nation states that the new states
"are abnormally susceptible to serious disaffection based on primordial attachments. By a primordial attachment is meant one that stems from the "givens" -- or, more precisely, as culture is inevitably involved in such matters, the assumed "givens" -- of social existence: immediate contiguity and kin connection mainly, but beyond them the givenness that stems from being born into a particular religious community, speaking a particular language, or even a dialect of a language, and following particular social practices." (Geertz, nd, p. 4)
These blood, speech, cultural and other such ties are held to be strong and in some cases coercive for when the individual is effectively bound by kinsmanship and so forth the outcome is not just affection on a personal basis or necessitated practicality or even common interest or some obligation that has been incurred. The varying strength of these ties is varied from one to another individual and from one society to another.
Discussion
It is difficult to discern whose
download full paper ⤓
Summary and Conclusion
The nation is best defined by the individuals that comprise that nation with the nation's definition fitting to the characteristics of its citizenry than attempting to mold the citizenry to 'fit' into the definition of the nation. This is because where no growth exists stagnation becomes dominant and with growth comes change evidenced in the 'tips' and 'cascades' that occur within society and the nation-at-lager. Of course there are some things that one cannot imaging changing since it is unlikely that Israel will ever become a Muslim nation and just as unlikely that the United States will assume a communist stance in politics. With that being said, perhaps a nation might be best viewed upon the basis of its guiding principles and beliefs that stand apart from any cultural, ethnic, or linguistic framework, which everyone understands, are principles that have served as the basis for the formation and growth of that nation.
Works Cited
Anderson, B. (1991) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. Verso.
Geertz, C. (n.d.) The Integrative Revolution: Primordial Sentiments and Civil Politics in the New States.
Hobsbawm (1980) Nations and Nationalism Since 1980. Cambridge: Cambridge… READ MORE
Quoted Instructions for "Nations and Nationalism Exist: Comparison" Assignment:
October 8: Building Nations and States
Anderson , Imagined Communities (selection)
Hobsbawm, Nations and Nationalism since 1780 (selection)
Geertz, *****Primordial and Civic Ties*****
Volkan, *****Psychoanalytic Aspects of Ethnic Conflicts,***** Conflict and Decision-Making
Laitin, Identity in Formation (selection)
Paper Option #1: Scholars are very divided on the origins and roles of "nations" in politics. They are split between four basic orientations. Some, like Volkan, take a Psychological Approach, arguing groups are necessary to us. Others, like Laitin, believe we have some control over our identity (known as "Instrumentalism). Many believe our identities are "given" at birth (Geertz discusses this notion of "Primordialism"). Finally, Constructivists like Hobsbawn view nationalism as modern, intertwined with industrialization and state-building, and ultimately about power and control over the government.
Read the Anderson first and make sure you understand his definition of a nation. Write a short essay on which author has the most persuasive argument for why we have nations and nationalism. In the essay, you must reference the Hobsbawm and at least two of the following three: Geertz, Volkan, and Laitin. You may find it useful to consider your own identity and feelings of national pride, although such reflections are not necessary in the essay. *****
How to Reference "Nations and Nationalism Exist: Comparison" Essay in a Bibliography
“Nations and Nationalism Exist: Comparison.” A1-TermPaper.com, 2013, https://www.a1-termpaper.com/topics/essay/nations-nationalism-exist-comparison/3414010. Accessed 17 Jun 2024.
Related Essays:
Nationalism and Martyrdom Symbolic Deaths in the American Revolution Thesis
Nationalism and Martyrdom: Symbolic Deaths in the American Revolution
The symbolic and ceremonial importance attached to the American Revolution and its martyrs, due to the beliefs held within the 'Nationalism'… read more
Thesis 25 pages (6813 words) Sources: 20 Style: Chicago Topic: Religion / God / Theology
Socialism Nationalism Term Paper
Socialism and Nationalism in Comparison
In trying to create a systematic, analytical comparison between socialism and nationalism, one is immediately struck with a very basic difference of type. Though both… read more
Term Paper 7 pages (2684 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Government / Politics
Nationalism, Gender, Thesis
Nationalism, Gender, And the Nation
The objective of this paper is to answer the question of whether policies of nationalist government modernize gender relations or do they represent a traditionalist… read more
Thesis 20 pages (5424 words) Sources: 16 Style: Chicago Topic: Sexuality / Gender
Nationalism We Live in a World Thesis
Nationalism
We live in a world that is constantly searching for its identity, one which is made up of state actors, non-state actors, organizations, corporations and leaders. They all have… read more
Thesis 14 pages (4601 words) Sources: 5 Style: APA Topic: World History
Nationalism National Building Process of Belgium Flemish Term Paper
Nationalism / National Building Process of Belgium
Flemish
Scientific research regarding nationalism gave a lot of theories, more or less disputed, that evolved and were improved in time. M. Crawford… read more
Term Paper 6 pages (1865 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Government / Politics
Mon, Jun 17, 2024
If you don't see the paper you need, we will write it for you!
We can write a new, 100% unique paper!